Every Thanksgiving, the same family gathers around the same dining room table. The food is familiar, the stories are predictable, and everyone knows which chair belongs to Grandpa. But sometimes, the most important things about a family are the things nobody talks about.

Consider a fictional family we’ll call the Millers.

For years, Linda Miller hosted Thanksgiving at the home where she and her late husband raised their three children. Now in her early seventies, Linda still enjoys preparing the holiday meal, welcoming her grandchildren, and keeping the family traditions alive. Her husband passed away several years ago, and she has been managing the household on her own ever since.

Her oldest daughter, Sarah, lives nearby and assumes she will eventually help manage the family home. Her son, Michael, lives out of state but believes their parents intended for the house to be divided equally among the children. Their youngest daughter, Emily, has always been especially attached to the property and privately hopes to keep it in the family.

Nobody has discussed these expectations with Linda.

During Thanksgiving dinner, someone casually asks whether Linda has thought about what she wants to happen to the house. She smiles and says, “I’ve taken care of everything. You kids don’t need to worry.”

Everyone is reassured, but nobody asks what that actually means.

Does Linda have a living trust? Has the property been transferred into it? Does everyone understand her wishes? Has she considered what would happen if she could no longer live independently?

The family leaves Thanksgiving believing they understand the situation. In reality, they each have a different picture of the future.

This scenario may be fictional, but the underlying situation is surprisingly common. Families often assume they understand one another’s intentions without ever having the conversations necessary to confirm them.

 

The Problem Isn’t Always a Lack of Planning

Many families assume that once a parent creates a will or living trust, everything is taken care of. But having legal documents in place and making sure the appropriate people understand the plan are two different things.

Research supports this disconnect.

According to Fidelity’s 2025 Family and Finance Study, 97% of surveyed families believe estate planning conversations are important, yet 68% of parents have not told their children what they may inherit or whether they will inherit anything at all.

Similarly, Pew Research Center’s 2025 survey found that among adults under 65 with parents age 65 or older, only 50% said a parent had discussed their wishes for medical care if they could no longer make decisions independently. Just 51% said a parent had discussed what should happen to their belongings after death.

These findings reveal something important: recognizing the importance of planning doesn’t necessarily mean families are communicating effectively.

Sometimes parents want to protect their privacy. Sometimes adult children worry that asking questions will make them appear interested in an inheritance. Other times, everyone simply assumes there will be an opportunity to discuss things later.

Unfortunately, those conversations can become much more difficult when an unexpected event forces the family to make decisions quickly.

When Everyone Has a Different Understanding of the Same Plan

Inheritance can be particularly complicated because family members may have very different expectations about what is fair.

In Linda’s fictional family, Sarah believes she will eventually manage the house because she has spent years helping her mother maintain it. Michael assumes everything will be divided equally because that is what he remembers his father saying. Emily believes the family home should remain with someone who appreciates its history.

None of them has bad intentions. They simply have different expectations.

Research from Wells Fargo’s 2026 Wealth Transfer Study highlights how these disagreements can affect families. Among adult children surveyed from families with at least $1 million in investable assets, 61% reported negative family experiences related to inherited wealth, including disagreements about fairness, hurt feelings, estrangement, and legal disputes.

The study also found that 49% of those adult children believed inheritance conversations could trigger family conflict.

These findings apply to a specific affluent population, not every American family, but they illustrate how quickly assumptions about inheritance can become personal.

This is why estate planning involves more than identifying beneficiaries. Families may also benefit from understanding the reasoning behind important decisions, particularly when property, family businesses, or sentimental belongings are involved.

As we explored in our previous article, “Estate Planning Preparation: 5 Things Every Family Should Have in Order,” having an estate plan is only part of being prepared. Families should also understand where important documents are located, who has been chosen to serve in key roles, and how financial information and other responsibilities can be accessed when needed. Making these details clear can help prevent confusion when loved ones eventually need to step in.

What Happens When the Unexpected Changes Everything?

Return to Linda’s story.

Imagine that several months after Thanksgiving, she experiences a medical emergency and can no longer manage her financial affairs independently.

Sarah wants to help pay the household bills. Michael wants to speak with the financial institutions. Emily wants to coordinate her mother’s care.

They all want to help, but who has the legal authority to act?

A durable financial power of attorney can designate someone to handle financial matters on Linda’s behalf. An Advance Health Care Directive can identify someone to make healthcare decisions if Linda cannot communicate them herself.

A revocable living trust may also establish arrangements for managing trust property during incapacity and distributing assets after death, depending on its terms and proper funding.

Without appropriate documents, families may face uncertainty or potentially need court involvement to obtain authority.

This is why estate planning should address both what happens after death and what happens during someone’s lifetime.

 

A Different Kind of Thanksgiving Conversation

None of this means Thanksgiving dinner should turn into a discussion about inheritance, financial accounts, or who gets the family home.

But it can be an opportunity to open the door.

Instead of asking parents how much money they plan to leave behind, consider asking whether they have thought about who they would trust to make decisions for them. Ask whether important documents are current or whether they have discussed their wishes with the people closest to them.

Parents can also take the opportunity to explain their intentions. They don’t necessarily need to disclose every financial detail, but making sure the appropriate people understand their responsibilities can prevent confusion later.

The goal isn’t to control what happens years from now. It’s to make sure family members aren’t left making assumptions about decisions that were important enough to put into a legal plan.

The Most Important Things Are Worth Talking About

In the Miller family’s story, the biggest problem wasn’t that the children didn’t care about their mother. It was that everyone believed they understood her wishes without ever asking.

Real families face similar situations every day.

At Shoup Legal, we help California families create and review estate plans that reflect their individual circumstances, priorities, and wishes. We also offer free educational estate planning workshops covering living trusts, wills, probate, powers of attorney, Advance Health Care Directives, and other important planning topics.

This Thanksgiving, enjoy the time with your family. Share the stories, enjoy the traditions, and appreciate the people around your table.

And if there are important questions your family has been putting off, consider making time to talk about them.

Visit EstatePlanningWorkshop.org to find an upcoming workshop and register for free.

This article uses a fictional family scenario for educational purposes. It is not based on an actual Shoup Legal client or matter. This article is intended for general educational purposes and does not provide individualized legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I tell my children about my estate plan?

You do not necessarily need to disclose every financial detail. However, communicating important decisions, identifying people who will serve in key roles, and explaining where documents are located can help your family understand what to expect.

Can siblings disagree over an inheritance even when there is a will or trust?

Yes. Legal documents provide instructions, but disagreements can still arise over family expectations, sentimental belongings, property, and how certain decisions are interpreted. Clear communication can help reduce misunderstandings.

Does a living trust explain why someone receives a particular inheritance?

A trust establishes legal instructions for managing and distributing property, but it may not communicate the personal reasoning behind every decision. Additional conversations or appropriate supporting documents can provide helpful context.

What happens if a parent becomes incapacitated without a power of attorney?

Depending on the circumstances, family members may need to seek court involvement to obtain authority to manage certain financial or personal affairs. A properly prepared power of attorney can help establish who may act on someone’s behalf.

How can families start discussing estate planning without creating tension?

Start with general questions about future wishes, healthcare preferences, and important responsibilities rather than immediately discussing inheritance amounts. Approach the conversation with curiosity and respect for everyone’s privacy. An educational estate planning workshop can also provide a neutral starting point.